CRIME - POLITICS - NIGHTLIFE - HOMETOWN: WEST CHESTER, CHESTER COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA

04 November 2009

2009 MUNICIPAL ELECTION - FINAL RESULTS

With all precincts reporting, Unplugged can safely call a few more races in the 2009 Municipal Election.

Out of 327,936 registered voters in the county, only 72,914 (22.2 percent) voters cast ballots today.

The Republicans have again swept the county row offices, to the surprise of very few (except maybe a few delusional moonbat liberals, who are undoubtedly also mourning the loss of the New Jersey gubernatorial race, in which the Republican former federal prosecutor Chris Christie defeated the Democrat incumbent Jon Corzine in the smartest thing the state of New Jersey has done in the past who knows how many years) – particularly when 18,276 Republican straight party tickets were cast, compared to 9,676 Democrat straight party tickets.

In the Treasurer's race, the former West Chester Borough Councilwoman Ann Duke defeated Democrat Barbara "Kipp" Stone by a vote of 41,854 to 26,004; the incumbent Comptroller Val DiGiorgio defeated Democrat Jim Reilly 41,738 to 27,635 to retain his seat, although there is some speculation that DiGirogio will seek the 6th Congressional seat currently being held by GOP gubernatorial candidate Jim Gerlach. Frank McElwaine defeated Democrat Mike McGann 42,438 to 26,429 in the race for Clerk of Courts, while Steven Dickter defeated Megan Lynott 42,180 to 26,968 in the race to replace retiring Coroner Robert Satriale.

In the Lionville District Court race, Republican candidate Lori Donatelli leads fellow Republican Gloria Satriale, who is running on the Democrat ticket after winning that primary election, by a nearly 3-to-1 margin. With all 13 precincts reporting, Donatelli – the wife of Upper Uwchlan supervisor Guy Donatelli – handily defeated Mrs. Satriale – the wife of the aforementioned retiring Coroner – by a 2,886 to 859 tally. The Lionville court includes Uwchlan, Upper Uwchlan, and West Pikeland, and is currently presided over by Stanley Scott, who will be retiring after nearly a quarter of a century on the bench dating back to when 15-2-07 also included West Whiteland and East Whiteland (before they were annexed into District Court 15-4-03 in 1993).

In the Avondale District Court race, controversial constable Matthew Seavey appears to have won the race to replace Thomas Martin, who retired late last year, defeating Democrat Clay Cauley 2,226 to 1,370, with all precincts reporting.

Other District Judges running for election ran unopposed, including Devon's Thomas Tartaglio, Valley's Grover Koon, Coatesville's Gregory Hines, Thorndale's Jeffrey Valocchi, and 15-1-04's resident leniency expert, Gwenn S. Knapp…

Meanwhile, President Judge Paula Francisco Ott now appears to be on her way to becoming one of four new members of the Superior Court. Judge Ott, a West Chester resident whose husband Ray is a former West Chester Borough Councilman, is currently third among nine candidates to fill four vacancies on the court. Two other Republicans, Judy Olson and Sallie Mundy lead the voting, with Judge Ott currently in 3rd nearly 97 percent of all votes state-wide having been counted. The fourth seat appears to have been narrowed down to two Democrats – Anne Lazarus and Robert Colville. The margin between the 4th place candidate Colville and the 5th place candidate Lazarus is approximately 3,500 votes; the margin when the report percentage was at 92 percent was slightly over 1,000 votes, so it would appear that Lazarus will be the fourth place finisher and win a seat on the Superior Court (click here for a county-by-county breakdown of the Superior Court election results).

It appears that not only will Chester County be seeking a new President Judge, but there will, at least for now, be one vacancy in the 2011 election for the Common Pleas Court. There's talk of at least one other Common Pleas Judge who is up for retention in 2011 who may choose not to seek a second 10-year term, though, it's probably too early to tell whether or not that will come to fruition.

The Superior Court race is not the only race where Republicans in Pennsylvania are feeling very confident. Superior Court Judge Joan Melvin Orie is leading Democrat Jack Panella 53 percent to 47 percent in the race to fill one vacancy on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court; Republicans Patricia McCullough (802,671) and Kevin Brobson (743,774) lead Democrats Linda Judson (665,299) and Barbara Berhend Ernsberger (657,159) in the race for two vacancies on the Commonwealth Court…

In the West Chester Area School District, Republicans swept the four open seats in what turned out to be one of the more contentious battles in the county. Republicans Heidi Adsett (7,961), John Wingerter (7,948), Sean Carpenter (7,847), and Maria Armandi Pimley (7,814) defeated the Democrat slate of Susan Tiernan (6,522), Susan Carty (6,329), Lisa Samuel (6,007), and Deborah Liczwek (5,902); the Republicans also swept the Dems in Thornbury, Delaware County.

West Chester borough races proved anti-climactic, as Dems ran unopposed in all four races and in the mayor's race. Holly Brown (1st Ward), Chuck Christie (3rd Ward) and John Manion (7th Ward) ran unopposed, while Thomas Paxton beat back a write-in campaign to replace Carolyn Comitta in the 5th Ward. Comitta was elected Mayor of West Chester after winning both the Democrat and Republican primaries in May.

In other mayoral races of interest, the former police officer and Republican Matt Fetick defeated Democrat Leslie Whiteside 400-214 in the race to replace Leon Spencer as mayor of Kennett Square. In Phoenixville, the Democrat incumbent Leo Scoda defeated Republican challenger Louis Amici 1,331 to 836. Democrats also won contested mayoral elections in Downingtown (Josh Maxwell defeated Nick Winkler 659-611) and South Coatesville (long time mayor James Kennedy defeated William Jones 85-59).

In the county's other boroughs, these candidates ran unopposed: Wesley Vincent (Atlgen), Doris Howell (Avondale), Arleigh Hegarty (Elverson), Maria Downey (Honey Brook), Gerald McGlone (Malvern), Ronald McCorkle (Modena), Geoffrey Henry (Oxford), John Hagan (Parkesburg), Michael Weiss (Spring City), and Stephen Black (West Grove)…

In the Coatesville City Council races, Democrat Karl Marking defeated the Republican Eric Lacerte 155-51 for the 4th Ward (East Side/South) Council seat. Democrats also swept the two at-large Council seats, as Jarrell Brazzle (578) and Joseph Hamrick (483) defeated Republicans Joseph DiSciullo (321) and Fran Schnering (225). Democrat Ingrid Jones ran unopposed for the 2nd Ward (South Side) seat.

In another interesting race in Coatesville, the former City Council President Kareem Johnson captured the 3rd Ward Constable race (North Side); the seat had been previously held by the late GOP turned Democrat power broker Richard Legree. The 5th Ward (East Side/North) race ended in a tie between the Democrat Ronald Suber and the Republican Ricky Campbell. Both candidates received 84 votes, so undoubtedly, there will be a recount…

And, finally, an Assistant District Attorney can now add another title to his resume – Downingtown Area School District Board Member.

Assistant District Attorney Thomas Ost-Prisco ran unopposed for the DASD Region 8 seat, which covers Downingtown Borough – West Ward/South Precinct, and West Bradford Precincts 2 and 4. Ost-Prisco is the lead prosecutor in the Coatesville arson cases that are pending in Common Pleas Court.

As time permits, I hope to have a more detailed breakdown of the key election results – or at least the WCASD race and perhaps a couple of others, though most of the contested races seem self-explanatory as far as a breakdown is concerned.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

WHO AM I?

My Photo
Creighton Rabs
West Chester, Pennsylvania, United States
I have lived in West Chester since 1995. For the past 2 years, Unplugged has covered crime and the courts, primarily in the West Chester area. With the launch of Unplugged v.2.0, the focus is expanding to include coverage of borough government meetings, comments about the borough's nightlife, and some random thoughts in general.
View my complete profile

GET PLUGGED IN...

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

MEET ME AT FACEBOOK

Creighton Rabs's Facebook profile

"THE GAME IS IN US"

UNPLUGGED V.2.0 ARCHIVE

STORY LABELS

COMMON TERMS/ABBREVIATIONS

1543 - The section of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Code relating to Driving a Motor Vehicle Under Suspension; 1543-A is a Non-DUI Related Suspension, 1543-B is a DUI Related Suspension
ARD - Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (program for non-violent first time offenders, mainly DUI cases, but not exclusive to DUI)
CCH - Chester County Hospital
CCP - Chester County Prison
GFAC - Good Fellowship Ambulance
IPP - Intermediate Punishment Program (alternative to full incarceration for certain non-violent offenses)
Lima Labs - The PSP Regional Laboratory in Lima, Middletown Twp, Delaware County; the mandated fee for DUI/Alcohol related testing is $70, the drug testing fee is $105
Medic 91 - CCH Paramedics
PWID - Possession With Intent to Deliver a Controlled Substance (ie. Drug Trafficking)
REAP - Recklessly Endangering Another Person
SCI - State Correctional Institute (aka State Penitentary)
Summary Disposition - An agreement between the Commonwealth and a defendant, usually at the District Court level, where misdemeanor are withdrawn in exchange for a guilty plea to a summary offense if certain conditions (ie. drug/alcohol treatment, community service, restitution) are complied with; non compliance can mean an automatic waiver to Common Pleas Court
TBUT - Theft by Unlawful Taking
Treatment Court - What the Common Pleas Court refers to as it's Restrictive Intermediate Punishment (similar to IPP, but for offenses graded as "Level 3 or 4" according to state sentencing guidelines)

OFFICE FINDER FOR JUSTICE CENTER

WEST Wing of Justice Center faces North New Street;
EAST Wing of Justice Center faces North Darlington Street


1ST Floor WEST

Sheriff's Office

1st Floor EAST

Cafeteria
Clerk of Courts
District Court 15-1-01
Prothonotary

2nd Floor WEST

Adult Probation and Parole
Register of Wills/Clerk of the Orphan's Court

2nd Floor EAST

Bail Agency/Pre-Trial Services
Law Library
Public Defender's Office

3rd Floor WEST

Juvenile Probation

3rd Floor EAST

Domestic Relations

4th Floor WEST

Court Administration

4th Floor EAST

Chester County Detectives
District Attorney
Warrant Enforcement Bureau

5th Floor WEST

Master's Rooms

5th Floor EAST

Court Reporters
Jury Commissioner's and Juror Assembly Room

6th Floor WEST

Courtrooms #9, #10, #11, and #12

6th Floor EAST

Courtrooms #14, #15, #16, #17, #18, and #19

7th Floor WEST

Courtrooms #1, #3, and #4

7th Floor EAST

Courtrooms #2, #5, #6, #7, and #8

COMMON PLEAS COURT JUDGES COURTROOM ASSIGNMENTS

CR #1 - President Judge Paula Francisco Ott
CR #2 - Judge Thomas Gavin
CR #3 - Judge Robert Shenkin
CR #4 - Judge William Mahon
CR #5 - Judge Howard F. Riley, Jr.
CR #6 - Judge David Bortner
CR #7 - Judge James P. MacElree II
CR #8 - Judge Ronald Nagle
CR #9 - (RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE)
CR #10 - Senior Judge Charles Smith
CR #11 - Judge Edward Griffith
CR #12 - Judge Anthony Sarcione
CR #13 - (NUMBER NOT USED)
CR #14 - Judge Phyllis Streitel
CR #15 - Judge John Hall
CR #16 - Judge Katherine Platt
CR #17 - Judge Jacqueline Cody
CR #18 - (RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE)
CR #19 - (RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE)

COMMON PLEAS COURT CRIMINAL TERMS

BORTNER (6)

Sept. 28-Oct. 9
Nov. 9-20

GAVIN (2)

Sept. 14-Oct. 2
Oct. 26-Nov. 6
Nov. 30-Dec. 12

MacELREE (7)

Oct. 26-Nov. 6

MAHON (4)

Sept. 14-Oct. 9
Oct. 26-Nov. 20
Dec. 7-18

NAGLE (8)

Oct. 12-23
Nov. 9-20

RILEY (5)

Oct. 5-16
Nov. 9-20
Dec. 14-18

SARCIONE (12)

Rotation I

Oct. 12-23
Nov. 23-Dec. 4

Rotation II

Sept. 28-Oct. 9
Nov. 9-20

STRIETEL (14)

Oct. 26-Nov. 6
Dec. 7-18

COMMON PLEAS COURT "SIGNING JUDGES"

The "signing" judge for the week has many purposes in Chester County:

Serve as the on-call judge available to sign warrants that fall under the jurisdiction of the Common Pleas Court (ie. wiretap warrants)
Hear all Protection From Abuse (PFA) orders - Mondays
Preside over the admission and removal hearings for the ARD program - Tuesdays
Preside over "72-hour" bench warrant hearings - Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays
Preside over appeals to PennDOT regarding driver license suspensions - Thursdays
Preside over video Gagnon I hearings - Fridays

Over the course of the signing judge's week, typically referred to as the Miscellaneous List (Misc. List), Gagnon II hearings, summary appeals, expungement hearings, sentencings, and pre-trial motions are also heard. On some weeks, other judges will have Misc. List matters, however the signing judge handles all of the above listed matters for the week.

2009

Sept. 28-Oct. 2: Shenkin
Oct. 5-9: Smith
Oct. 12-16: Streitel
Oct. 19-23: Mahon
Oct. 26-30: Sarcione
Nov. 2-4: Smith
Nov. 5-6: Ott
Nov. 9-13: Shenkin
Nov. 16-20: Gavin
Nov. 23-24: Hall
Nov. 25: MacElree
Nov. 30-Dec. 4: Mahon
Dec. 7-11: Bortner
Dec. 14-18: Griffith

DISTRICT COURT AFTER-HOURS "ON CALL" SCHEDULE

The On-Call District Judges handle preliminary arraignments for criminal cases, issue emergency Protection From Abuse orders, and accept bail postings outside of the District Court system's normal hours.

The below schedule may be subject to change. To confirm who the on-call MDJ is, contact Chester County Police Radio at (610) 383-7000.

The 2009 schedule listed below is a tentative listing based on the current schedule cycle. The confirmed 2010 District Court on-call schedule will be posted once it becomes available from Court Administration.

November 2009

27: MDJ Kraut/West Goshen (20:00-23:30 only)
28-29: MDJ Cabry/Honey Brook
30: MDJ Scott/Lionville

December 2009

1-2: MDJ Scott/Lionville
3-5: MDJ D'Angelo/Pottstown
6-8: MDJ Maisano/Kennett
9-11: MDJ Farmer/Oxford
12-14: MDJ Cabry/Honey Brook
15-17: MDJ Gill/Parkesburg
18-20: MDJ Blackburn/Chesterbrook
21-23: MDJ Valocchi/Thorndale
24-26: MDJ Smith/Exton
27-29: Avondale
30-31: MDJ Knapp/Union Street

FRIENDS OF UNPLUGGED